Monday, February 26, 2018
Conferences for This Week!
Remember, if you haven't signed up for a confernece, please come at one of the available times below, or e-mail me for another time. This is all we're doing this week, so if you miss your conference, it's like missing two classes! All conferences are in my office, HM 348, right next to our classroom. See you then!
Wednesday
11:00: Amanda
11:10: Matthew
11:20 Nathaniel
11:30 Stacy
11:40 Nathen
11:50 Penny
1:00 Lizbeth
1:10-1:50 OPEN
2:00 Coleman
2:10-2:30 OPEN
Thursday
11:00: Kelsey
11:10-:20: OPEN
11:30 Benjamin
11:40 Halie
11:50 Kasandra
Friday
11:00 Joel
11:10 Annabell
11:20 Riley
11:30 Mitchell
11:40 Kayla
11:50 OPEN
1:00 Japeth
1:10-2:30 OPEN
Thursday, February 22, 2018
Conversation Paper #1: The Monsters Are Real!
I: In “The Real Question,” the alien known as Mxyzptlk says, “we are gods. You are just puppets. As long as there’s one of you, there’ll be a hundred of us.” By this he seems to mean that we can never tell all of our stories (there are too many of us), but we can tell one of their stories, since they can live in a million minds for a thousand years. In this way, the science fiction world of aliens, monsters, and superheroes can represent in an immediate, universal way the struggles of identity we all experience. We don’t have to tell our story...we can tell Superman’s story, since his alter ego is us—the awkward, coming-of-age outsider in a world we don’t understand.
Q: For your first conversation paper, I want you to introduce people to the conversation: why do superheroes, aliens, and monsters help tell the story of our identity as teenagers, adults, Americans, or “others.” We all feel like we’re on the outside at some point in our lives, as none of us are truly normal. We might be from another country, speak another language, have strange abilities and talents, or seem to have none of the right abilities and talents. An alien trying to make it in America is a great way to explore these very human difficulties, particularly when this alien has extraordinary (but secret) powers that might make others fear or distrust him. Similarly, even being a teenager is to be an “outsider,” since adults distrust you, fear you, suspect you, and tell you what to think. What ‘powers’ do teenagers have that adults forgot they even had...and how do you use these to become a ‘superhero,’ at least to those you love?
R: You must use at least TWO of the chapters from Superman: American Alien in your discussion. Remember, you’re introducing the idea that superheroes, aliens, and monsters can represent real-world identity to people who have probably never read a superhero comic. So what do you need to explain to them? What do they need to know and see? Use two of the stories to show us why Superman is relevant to a modern American teenager or adult. ALSO, I want you to use at least one of the following stories by Dale Bailey in Best American SF/F, “Teenagers from Outer Space” and/or “I Was a Teenage Werewolf.” The goal is to make these works contribute to a conversation about ‘coming of age’ in our society through the metaphors of “others”—superheroes, etc.
Length: At least 5 pages, double spaced (though you can do more)
Format: Be sure to quote passages from the comic and at least one of the stories according to MLA format or another you prefer (but be consistent). You must cite page numbers and include a Works Cited page
Due: Monday, February 26th by 5pm [no class that day]
Monday, February 19, 2018
For Wednesday: Bailey, “I Was a Teenage Werewolf” (pp.286-303)
Answer TWO of the following:
Q1: In the previous story, the town prefers to see Johnny “as
a hero who’d saved humanity from the ascension of triumphant alien overlords”
(55). How does this story also prefer to believe a convenient narrative of
heroism/safety? Who is the hero? Who is the villain? What truths or taboos is
the town hiding from?
Q2: Who is the narrator in the story? Even though he/she
doesn’t introduce themselves as Nancy did, how can we tell who they are? Why do
you think he tells the story from this perspective rather than giving the
narrator a name and a character? How does it change the story?
Q3: The narrator claims that the anonymity of the werewolf
gave them a certain power in their community. As he/she explains, “if we were
both sovereign and slave to our terror, our teachers and parents were slaves
alone. As long as no one knew who the teenage werewolf was, it could be any one
of us” (296). Why does this give them power over their teachers and parents? How
does this bond the teenagers together as a group?
Q4: The ending of the this story is surprising and a bit
shocking: why do you think Bailey ends the story with all the adults being
eaten/murdered? Is the point of the story to say “teenagers are evil and can’t
be trusted”? Or does he have another intention? Why make every teenager a werewolf and every adult a victim?
Saturday, February 17, 2018
For Monday: Bailey, “Teenagers from Outer Space” (pp.27-55)
Q1: How might this story be a version of Superman if
instead of one alien, a hundred aliens descended on Smallville? How can we tell
that both Bailey and Landis (Superman: American Alien) are sharing the
same conversation about the acceptance “others” in the heart of America ?
Q2: The entire story is told from Nancy Miller’s viewpoint,
and by her own admission, “much of what follows is reconstructed from
second-hand reports, with all the bias and self-interest inherent in such
accounts” (29). Do we trust her version of events? Is there anyplace where it
seems she adds her own bias or opinions into the mix? Or does she help us see
the limitations of others’ biases and values?
Q3: Writing about Johnny (who is proclaimed as a hero after
the aliens leave town), Nancy says,
“Maybe he thought he was innocent, courageous, whatever...People do it all the
time. People want to be blameless. People want to be brave” (47-48). Who is the
hero of this story? If this is a traditional aliens vs. humans story, who
“saved the world”? For the reader, who is most brave and selfless? And why
might the people telling the story later not see this?
Q4: How might this story be a metaphor for women growing up
in American society, especially in the 1950’s? What might Bailey mean that every
woman has to choose between “freedom” and “slavery,” or “aliens” and “duty”? Why
might he also explain why Joan makes the decision she does?
Wednesday, February 14, 2018
For Friday: Landis, Superman: American Alien, “Eagle,” “Angel,” and “Valkyrie”
Answer TWO of the following:
Q1: In “Angel,” Pete is arguing with Clark about the future
of Superman and what role he intends to play in society. He finally tells him, “Superman
will never be able to retire.” What is it that Pete sees that Clark doesn’t
here? Why is Superman bigger than one hero or one alien or one costume? (and
related to this, why should he start
talking to the other people who are “like
him” in the world)?
Q2: In “Eagle,” Clark reflects that “It feels good to help
people. No, I’m not afraid…what’s there to be afraid of?” What hasn’t he
figured out yet about being a super hero, and how do the next three stories
show him why there’s a lot to be
afraid about? Also, why is a superhero more than simply saving lives and
feeling good about yourself?
Q3: “Valkyrie” is the only comic that doesn’t have the name
of a bird. What is a Valkyrie, and
why is this significant to the comic? Why end the bird metaphors with this
title? What changes in this comic that we don’t see completely (or as
developed) in the others?
Q4: Each one of these comics is about taking a large step
into adulthood from the illusions (and delusions, sometimes) of childhood. If
we stop reading this as a superhero comic and consider that it symbolizes what
we all go through in this process, which
comic relates the most to our journey? What can Superman teach us about our own
identity as we become a new, more responsible person capable of saving the
world day in, and day out?
Friday, February 9, 2018
For Monday: Superman: American Alien, “Parrot” and “Owl” (and the two mini-comics between them)
Answer TWO of the following:
Q1: “Parrot” seems to allude to the fact that parrots can imitate human speech and ‘pretend’ to be something they’re not. While
Q2: The style of these two chapters is dramatically different from one another and from the pervious comics, as “Parrot” is bright and humorous, while Owl is angular, fuzzy, and tense. Why might Superman in particular be so adaptable to all these different stories and approaches? It might be harder, for example, to tell a Batman or Wonder Woman story this way.
Q3: In “Owl,” Clark Kent meets Superman’s arch-rival, Lex Luthor, and has a one-on-one interview with him (though of course Luthor doesn’t know who he really is). During this interview, Luthor tells him “People aren’t important. Not as a whole...That’s why you see people throughout history rising above the masses. Those are the changers. Those are the doers. You are not important. You’re not. I am.” How are we supposed to read this speech? Is it true? Is he helping Clark to understand/embrace his own identity? Could these words ever be expressed by a superhero? Or are they fundamentally a sociopath’s point of view?
Q4: In the short comic after “Parrot,” which is entitled “The Real Question,” the alien known as Mxyzpltlk breaks down the “fourth wall” and talks directly to the reader. Why are comics able to do this more effectively than a traditional novel? And what does he mean by the sentence, “We are gods. You are just puppets”?
Monday, February 5, 2018
For Wednesday: Landis, Superman: American Alien (“Dove” and “Hawk”)
NOTE: Read the first two stories/chapters of the book, "Dove" and "Hawk" for Wednesday's class. If you're confused about where to stop, you can stop reading where you see the full page of Clark on a boat with a with a bunch of women and champagne glasses.
Answer TWO of the following:
Q1: Discuss how the art in one of the chapters helps to tell
the story, and is also appropriate for that story. Why would this story be much
different if we just had the words? Discuss at least one specific panel or page
in your response.
Q2: What does Clark mean in “Dove”
when he tells his father, “When you break something, you’re not just breaking
the thing, you’re like...hurting everyone who made it the way it was”? Why
might this also say something about Clark ’s relationship
to his powers and his mysterious identity as an “alien”?
Q3: In class on Monday we discussed how modern heroes, and
especially super heroes, are often more “gray” than “white,” and how they often
resemble the “dragons” in fantasy stories. How does “Hawk” discuss the thin
line between being a hero and a villain for Clark ?
According to this story, what makes him a hero rather than a “monster”?
Q4: In-between the two chapters, there is a two-page
illustration called “The Castaways.” How does it connect the two stories
without “telling” us outright? Why can
single picture do this even more powerfully than a paragraph or an
entire story?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)