For Friday: Marshall, “Destroy the City With Me Tonight” (pp.13-21)





Group “A” / “SF” should answer TWO of the following:

Q1: In her reflections on the story, Kate Marshall writes that “it is a story about grappling with identities into which it is too easy to vanish—losing who we are in what we are” (350). According to this story, why might being a superhero (or anyone with a secret calling) gradually overtake you and make your real life vanish?

Q2: The story has a strange metaphor at its center: that every person with Caspar-Williams Syndrome has a literal city written on their body, and to ease their suffering, they have to find that city and defend it. While this kind of makes sense for a superhero (since each one has their own city—Gotham, Metropolis, etc.), how might the metaphor translate for normal people?

Q3: In the beginning of the story, Cass chooses a superhero identity, Seraph, and decides on a mask to wear. As she reflects, “She’s always wondered why you’d bother with a mask; now she gets it. It’s not to be concealed, it’s to be seen, to be remembered” (14). How might this relate to the comment in Ms. Marvel about her becoming an “urban legend”?

Q4: Before she kills him, the villain named Nightblade asks her to “Destroy the city with me…Destroy the city and we’ll be free” (19). Why would destroying the city make her free and allow her to leave? In real-world terms, what might he be asking her to do? Why doesn’t she agree?






Comments